The Crazy Simple Life

A few things we've learned along the way...

Home

Confession: Yelling Doesn't Work

Posted on April 4, 2012 at 8:00 AM




Photo by www.mymommymanners.com

 


Confessions.  Molly, Ellie and I decided to include confessions as a part of our blog posts.  These aren’t “I don’t make my dinner rolls from scratch" type confessions.  They are the type of confessions that require inner reflection, self-evaluation and sometimes a life learning that forces you to change your course the next time. They are not easy to write about.  


Here is my confession. 

 

Have you ever heard of a “Monster Mom”?  Monster Mom is a term some mothers use to describe themselves when they are having a bad parenting day.  When for whatever reason, fatigue, stress or everyday life chaos makes you crack. This week, I had a Monster Mom moment. 

 

I yelled (like, really yelled) at my 2 year-old son. He was not happy about having his diaper changed, which is often the case when he has a messy diaper. He was crying, flailing his feet and squirming around, causing ‘the mess’ to get all over the changing table.  I couldn’t help but yell,“STOP IT! I DON’T WANT TO BE DOING THIS EITHER AND YOU NEED TO HELP MOM!”  It was kind of like a yell and a hiss at the same time.

 

He only cried and flailed harder. 

 

It wasn’t the words that were awful; it was the yelling and out-of-control emotion I felt. In addition to the volume, I was also squeezing his ankles to get his attention - and wishing I had the ability to squeeze them harder. Nice one, Monster Mom; when the yelling doesn’t work resort to ankle-squeezing.  

Later, the guilt forced me to reflect. 

 

Did my son stop his tantrum when I yelled?  No.

Did my yelling teach him a lesson?  No, he only cried harder and became more upset. 

 

My own mother had tried to pass along this lesson to me, but maybe I needed to learn it for myself. She had told me on a few occasions the story of when I was a child, she was yelling at me and asked if I understood why. I answered, “I understand that you are yelling.” 

 

Well…that about sums it up doesn’t it? 

 

I realized that yelling is not the means to teach my child. Yes, maybe there are those rare occasions when your child is running towards the street and you have to yell in hopes of getting their attention. But it is those other occasions when I am frustrated at his behavior that I know yelling will not teach him anything.  He will be too upset to process my words and we will both walk away confused, one of us with much more guilt than the other. At least until the next time he has a messy diaper and starts thrashing his feet once again.

 

I had to force myself not to feel guilty for too long. I know I will remember the incident way longer than my 2 year-old son will. Occasionally, Monster Mom comes out, and occasionally, it is a stress-relief-matter-of-survival thing for me. And hey, if at least I learned something as a mom, it can’t be all bad, right?

 


Categories: Fun for Kids, Self Stuff

Post a Comment

Oops!

Oops, you forgot something.

Oops!

The words you entered did not match the given text. Please try again.

Already a member? Sign In

19 Comments

Reply hannah
04:34 PM on April 29, 2012 
I enjoyed your blog and yes, you will probably remember for a long time. My kids are older, but there are still things I remember and they still tear at my heart -- wish I could do them over
Hannah P.S.
Join the fun, submit a cute photo or funny photo to my website contest. Then encourage your friends to vote and watch the results to see how many viewers vote for your photo. NO entry fee. $2,000 of prizes annually. www.FunnyPhotosContest.com.
Reply Denise
08:35 AM on April 19, 2012 
It can be really tough to keep from yelling. I really try but sometimes my emotions get the best of me. Visiting from SITS!
Reply Jamie and Lindsi
02:32 PM on April 16, 2012 
Ugh. Both Lindsi and I are yellers and we wish we weren't. Happy SITS day a little late!
Reply AnnMarie
11:37 PM on April 14, 2012 
The timing of this post is perfect. Just today, I did the ankle squeeze with my two year old. I sometimes think I yell so I won't hit but that is no excuse. I grew up in a yelling house and lived in a house with yelling girls in college and now, it is just a way to communicate in this house with four kids. I realized it was bad when my youngest was yelling instead of talking to say the most basic things. I need to work on my inside voice. Thanks for making me feel like I am not the ony one! Great read.
Reply Classic NYer
02:25 PM on April 14, 2012 
I think that's pretty true across the board, even for those of us who are not parents. Yelling and getting overemotional usually does not get the desired response out of your husband, your boss, your coworkers, your mother, etc.

Things I've learned the hard way: that.

Happy SITS day!
Reply thedoseofreality
05:12 PM on April 13, 2012 
Oh yeah, Monster Mom is a good way to describe that feeling for sure! I applaud you if you are able to make this a "one and done" lesson! ;) You will be a better mom than me for sure!
Reply krystle
03:56 PM on April 13, 2012 
I have those monster mom moments too. It's just like something snaps and I can't help but yell. I hate when I do that. It makes me feel so bad in the end.
Reply CC Jen
08:30 PM on April 12, 2012 
Wow! I need to print this out and keep it so I can look at it when I start losing my temper. Incidentally, my kids call me "Momster" sometimes :)
Reply alyce@culinarythymes
03:28 PM on April 12, 2012 
I've been there! Enjoy your SITS day!
Reply OneMommy
01:29 PM on April 12, 2012 
Thank you for your confession. We all have those moments; sometimes it's nice to be reminded we aren't alone.
I've been trying to do less yelling - and I have to say the 3 and 4.5 year olds are really making me work on this...
You're right, they don't listen just b/c you are screaming. If anything they tune you out.

Stopping by to say happy SITS day!
Reply Laura
11:12 AM on April 12, 2012 
You son will not remember it. Unless you tell him about it. Two things I do when Monster Mom comes out (I've found myself yelling to inflict guilt on them!)....ask forgiveness and when the feelings start to overwhelm, if at all possible, give myself a time out. It shocks them and steadies me. Thanks for sharing. It takes guts. Happy SITS day.
Reply Pam
11:04 AM on April 12, 2012 
I think most parents have had a yelling moment that they later regret. I know i have. (When your child is about 13, you might have one or two.) Don't feel guilty! (Sure, right. Telling a mom not to feel guilty is sort of a waste, isn't it?) Stopped by from SITS.
Reply Rachel {Raw-kul} @ StyleMentor.US
09:56 AM on April 12, 2012 
This one brought back a memory. I still wince when I think of the time I screamed at my oldest 5 year old daughter in the kitchen. She just stood there and I was screaming and losing it. It was over something stupid, but my hormones were raging and I was unable to stop it. When I stood back and looked at the moment, I decided that it should never happen again and it didn't. Just catching myself though, and realizing "it can never happen again" was part of the process of never letting it happen again. Reflection is key and makes us stronger. Thank you for being brave and confessing this.
Reply Carla K.
09:19 AM on April 12, 2012 
Well... a stinky diaper is a stinky diaper and no one wants to get the "stink" all over the place except a 2 year old.

I think you just had a bad day as most of us have from time to time. My advice... POTTY TRAINING... it's time. Then that way your son will have "control" of his body funcitons (or at least he will try to have control until he is successful)

Personally, I think that when children are playing in "their own world" they really don't want to be disturbed; not even for a pile of "stink". Cheer up mom... you can win some battles and you will lose others. It does not lessen that you and your sone have for each other. And that's just the way it is.
Reply Tara @ secretsofamomaholic.com
09:02 AM on April 12, 2012 
As long as you realize it- your not a monster mommy....when you dont realize your acting like a monster- its time to worry!!

We all have bad days- dont beat yourself up. But I do agree- yelling does more harm than good.
Reply ilene
08:26 AM on April 12, 2012 
Amie, LOVE this post. I can totally relate to "Monster Mom" moments and admire your honesty for writing about it. Even good moms crack. Better moms crack and then take a look at the behavior and try to change it next time around. Happy SITS day! xo
Reply another jennifer
08:14 AM on April 12, 2012 
Been there, done that. You're completely right that yelling doesn't accomplish a thing. If I yell, I go back and talk about why I was upset and how I could have handled it better. No one likes to get yelled at. We're not perfect, but we can learn from these type of experiences.
Reply Louise Ducote
06:44 AM on April 12, 2012 
Good for you! Maybe this will get through to some other mamas before they yell. I was yelled at as a kid and I remember only the chaotic feeling of the out-of-control adult, not the lesson I was supposed to be learning.
Reply Race Car Daughter
02:13 PM on September 21, 2011 
Very well said Amie! You described what every mother feels when those moments come. I remember being so frustrated with my oldest son (yes, The Philosopher) that I grabbed the closest thing to me -- a hairbrush -- and whacked him. (Talk about confessions here!). But afterword, the guilt was horrible. What if the closest thing to me had been something like, say a hammer? From that moment on I tried, really tried, not to lose it ever again, or at least not get physical. For the most part it worked, up until years later when my youngest son used a permanent marker to decorate the newly painted and wallpapered dining room that I'd spent days working on. A very, very tired mom left a bright red hand mark on said child's bottom. All of the older kids remember my fit to this day.
So, what to do? When I taught preschool, it was I who learned the most. When the class got loud and hyper and I wanted to scream, I started whispering -- sometimes to just one child at a time -- until they all stopped moving and shouting in order to hear me. Soon we were all under control, including the teacher. Well, what do you know?! A quiet voice was more effective than joining in the yelling.

Thanks for the well written and important reminder, Amie. Now I have to learn (at this late date) that yelling at one's husband might not be such a good idea either! At least with him there's no guilt involved. I KNOW that I'm right.

Follow Me on Pinterest


View my Tasty Kitchen Profile


Women Online